When Empowerment Leads to Impoverishment: A Case of Sanimart Project in Bhola District, Bangladesh
Abstract:
This
study was conducted in Bhola district of Barisal Division in Bangladesh. The purpose
of the study was to conduct a careful analysis of the plights of working adolescents
who are also attending schools, to find out whether UNICEF project being implemented
by COAST Trust is actually leading to the intended objective of adolescent empowerment.
I organized focus group discussions reaching a total of 60 adolescents. Educational
pass records of a total of 120 students were reviewed and compared to ascertain
whether the work of the children has potential correlations with their pass grades.
I
conclude that the empowerment project has instead caused disempowerment of the adolescent
girls because of a number of reasons; long working hours are so detrimental for
the girls given that the girls have to attend school and after schools proceed to
work for additional 4 hours, and perhaps perform other domestic works in their households,
the remuneration of girls is very low but being so helpless, they cannot complaint
about the unfair wages for which they work daily, the speak up culture which is
so much required in empowerment situation is not available in the work places of
the girls, the girls leave their work places at night which could expose them to
other sexual harassment scenarios in a very conservative environment, the working
environment could endanger the health of the young girls since they are dealing
with cotton materials which may lead to respiratory related diseases, and finally,
the extra work time has to a larger extent led to the low pass grades of the girls
in schools.
Certain
measures could be taken to avert or reduce the impact of working adolescents such
as: girls who are below the minimum required age for work can appoint their parents
or representatives to work on their behalf while close scrutiny is maintained to
ensure the girls benefit from the proceeds of their work. The entrepreneurs can
be compelled by Ministry of Women and Children Affairs (MOWCA) to ensure they pay
necessary minimum wage that is commensurate with the work of the adolescent girls.
Finally, the employers must be compelled to reduce the number of working hours to
ensure the girls can reach their houses before dark as well as by allowing them
a day off in a week.
Keywords:
Empowerment, impoverishment, agent, empoweree, disempowerment, child labor, Power
differentials, economic influence.
References:
[1]. Bureau
of International Labor Affairs (2015). Bangladesh,
moderate advancement. Working paper.
[2]. Child
Care and Protection Act (2013). The Child
Care and Protection Act. Laws of Bangladesh.
[3]. Eerdewijk,
Anouka van et al (2017). White paper: a conceptual
model of women and girls’ empowerment. Amsterdam: Royal Tropical Institute (KIT).
[4]. Hamed,
Said Shaban (2010). Antecedents and Consequences
of Employees Empowerment. Management Review: An International Journal Volume
5 Number 1 Summer 2010.
[5]. Harriger,
Alka R., Lutes, Kyle D., and Ricci, Rosemary (2001). The negative impact of too
much empowerment. Purdue University. IACIS 2001.
[6]. Ke,
Weiling and Zhang, Ping (2010). Effects of
Empowerment on Performance in Open-Source Software Projects. IEEE Transactions
on Engineering Management.
[7]. Marcus,
Rachael, and Page, Ella (2016). Girls’ learning
and empowerment - the role of school environments. United Nations Girls Education
Initiative’s policy brief.
[8]. Murari*,
Krishna (2013). Abusive leadership – a Barrier
to Employee Empowerment. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839
(Online) Vol.5, No.4, 2013
[9]. Riger,
Stephanie (1993). What’s wrong with empowerment.
Article in American Journal of Community Psychology · June 1993 DOI: 10.1007/BF00941504.
[10]. Ross,
Kara L. (2015). The Health Effects of Women
Empowerment: Recent Evidence from Northern Ghana. International Food and Agribusiness
Management Review Volume 18 Issue 1, 2015
[11]. Ukil,
Minhajul Islam (2016). The impact of employee
empowerment on employee satisfaction and service quality: empirical evidence from
financial enterprises in Bangladesh. Verslas: Teorija ir praktika / Business:
Theory and Practice. Doi:10.3846/btp.2016.651
[12]. UNICEF
(2010). Child labour in Bangladesh. UNICEF’s
working paper.
[13]. Vildö,
Lovisa (2017). The universal causes and effects
of women’s empowerment for developing countries. Uppsala Universitet.
[14]. Weidenstedt,
Linda (2016). Empowerment Gone Bad: Communicative
Consequences of Power Transfers. Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic
World Volume 2: 1–11. DOI: 10.1177/2378023116672869
[15]. Yıldırım,
Fatih and Yıldırım, Seda Kayapalı (2016). Effects
of cynicism on empowerment in organizations. Journal of Human Sciences, Volume:
13 Issue: 3 Year: 2016.